Recover.
The 1900 hurricane that hit Galveston, Texas is an excellent example of how things were before the creation of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). The argument could easily be made that recovery from major storms and the like was faster and more efficient back in the day, the times before federal government *management* of natural disaster situations.
Making landfall on September 8, 1900, The Galveston Hurricane of 1900 was documented as a category 4 hurricane and is the most deadly and second most damaging natural disaster ever to strike the United States. Official records list the death toll at 8,000 and damages costing in excess of $99 billion (2005 dollars).
There was no FEMA back then. So how on earth did Galveston recover? Hard work. The people of Texas and the city of Galveston didn't stand around waiting for federal government assistance. They rolled up their sleeves and went to work. Survivors constructed "storm lumber" homes, temporary shelter using salvageable material from the debris. Others got with the U.S. Army and set up surplus tents along the shore. Four days after the storm the city started receiving mail again. On day five, basic water service was restored and telegraph service was back in operation. Within three weeks, the port was again busy shipping out cotton.
We don't need FEMA.
In contrast, there's Hurricane Katrina that hit New Orleans August 23, 2005. Katrina claimed 1,800 lives and inflicted damages costing about $105 billion (2005 dollars). Reconstruction was hindered by FEMA mismanagement. Power didn't start getting restored to the city until September 5, that's 12 days after the storm. The Port of New Orleans was opened on September 6, but only to receive relief ships, not conduct business. Commercial business wouldn't start back up for another two weeks. The first section of the city to have a "boil water" order lifted was on October 6 and the city's 9th ward didn't get the "boil water" order lifted until a year later . And remember the FEMA trailer fiasco, you know, laced with formaldehyde? People given FEMA provided *shelter* ended up with headaches, bloody noses, breathing problems and an assortment of other ills.
We don't need FEMA.
A more recent hurricane, Sandy, struck the east coast on October 25, 2012 and nailed New York City the hardest. It caused the death of 285 people and inflicted about $50 billion in damage (2012 dollars). An estimated 1.8 million people were still without power 15 days after the storm hit. Boil water orders started getting rescinded in certain areas on November 6 but didn't wrap up until December 3. With Sandy, the most KUDOS can go out to the American Red Cross who immediately stepped in and provided access to food, water and temporary shelter .
The performance of FEMA pales in comparison to the Galveston recovery. it's not even close.
In all three examples, the most efficient, the most expeditious recovery efforts was conducted by the state and the impacted communities, NOT FEMA! It was neighbors helping neighbors, businesses helping other businesses, volunteers, church organizations and non-profits pitching in to fill the gaps that got things done. NOT FEMA. With Sandy, specialists from out-of-state, medical professionals, emergency response personnel, electricians, construction outfits traveled to the east coast to help out. They did some heavy lifting, NOT FEMA!
We don't need FEMA. Why do we send money to Washington to an organization that truly is not needed, to an organization that has a track record of mismanaging things and only causing delay to and getting in the way of reconstruction efforts? That hard-earned taxpayer money that FEMA gets should never go to Washington, it should stay in the states it comes from.
FEMA requested a budget of more than $13.5 billion for fiscal year 2013.
Galveston didn't need FEMA, the city recovered faster without their existence. FEMA did MUCH more documented harm than good with Katrina. FEMA stood around and watched other people roll up their sleeves with Sandy.
WTF?
PROPOSED: Terminate FEMA, effective immediately. Return that $13+ billion to the states.
Recent Comments